2. Choose the problem that can be solved using only natural numbers.
A: Roko is making a spice mix. The mix is 2 parts garlic powder, 1 part paprika and 1 part cayenne pepper. He wants to make 3 tablespoons of the spice. How many tablespoons of garlic powder should he use?
B: Logan is making a spice mix. The mix is 2 parts garlic powder, 1 part paprika and 1 part cayenne pepper. He wants to make 8 tablespoons of the spice. How many tablespoons of garlic powder should he use?
Solution
Analyzing problem A: The spice mix has 4 parts but Roko is only making 3 tablespoons. He will need to use a fraction of a tablespoon for the garlic powder. Fractions are not natural numbers so this problem cannot be solved using only natural numbers.
Analyzing problem B: The spice mix has 4 parts. Logan is making 8 tablespoons. 8 is twice as many as 4 so Logan can make 8 tablespoons of the mix by using tablespoons equal to twice the number of parts for each spice. Since each part is a whole number, twice the number of parts will also be a whole number. This problem can be solved using only natural numbers.
Problem B is the correct choice.